When Top Investors Lose Big – Lessons from Costly Mistakes

In partnership with

Get Your Advanced LBO Model

1️⃣ The $4 Billion Disaster That Nearly Ended Ackman’s Career

Bill Ackman is known for taking bold bets. Sometimes, they pay off. Other times, they go horribly wrong. His investment in Valeant Pharmaceuticals was one of his worst.

In early 2015, his hedge fund, Pershing Square, bet big on Valeant. The company had an aggressive strategy — acquiring smaller drug-makers, cutting costs, and hiking prices. Ackman believed it was the future of efficient drug pricing. He wasn't alone. Valeant stock soared, and analysts praised its model.

Then things unraveled. Reports surfaced that Valeant was inflating sales through a hidden network of pharmacies. Allegations of price gouging followed. Soon, regulators got involved. Investors panicked. The stock collapsed.

Ackman's fund lost several billion on the trade. Investors lost confidence. Lawsuits followed. His reputation took a major hit. As he later admitted on Lex Fridman’s podcast, joining Valeant’s board made him realize the mess was far worse than he thought. But by then, he was stuck.

How he bounced back: Instead of hiding, Ackman faced the mistake head-on. He admitted his errors, eventually sold his stake, and refocused on activist investing — his core strength. Over time, Pershing Square recovered, proving that even massive losses don't have to be the end — if you adapt quickly enough.

Lesson? No matter how strong your conviction, if the facts change, cut your losses.

2️⃣ The Blowup That Nearly Killed Citadel

Ken Griffin built Citadel into one of the most powerful trading firms in the world. But in 2008, it almost disappeared.

As the financial crisis unfolded, Citadel's flagship fund lost 55% in just months. The entire market was in turmoil, but Citadel had a particular problem: heavy exposure to structured credit and convertible bonds — two areas that collapsed when liquidity dried up.

Its highly leveraged positions became a liability when counterparties started pulling back. Prime brokers tightened lending, making it harder to meet margin calls. Investors feared Griffin would be forced to shut down. The situation was dire. Griffin had to decide: sell assets at fire-sale prices or fight to keep the firm alive.

How he bounced back: Griffin didn't panic. He imposed tight liquidity controls, cut risk, and secured critical funding. Importantly, regulators helped by pressuring Wall Street firms, not to pull the plug. Instead of liquidating at distressed prices, Griffin negotiated credit lines and locked in additional financing. He also halted investor redemptions, buying time to stabilize the firm.

By 2012, Citadel had fully rebounded. Today, it manages over $60 billion in assets and follows Griffin's hard-learned principle: "Don't act like a bank, unless you are a bank."

Lesson? Liquidity is everything. If you can survive, you can rebuild.

3️⃣ The Genius Who Couldn’t Beat the Market (At First)

Jim Simons is the godfather of quant trading. But before he cracked the market, he struggled hard.

Unlike most Wall Street prodigies, Simons entered finance late at the age of 40. A world-class mathematician, he had spent years breaking codes for the NSA and teaching geometry. But he believed algorithms could outsmart human intuition in markets.

His early models faced challenges. The equations were elegant, but the markets were messy. His fund, Renaissance Technologies, initially underperformed expectations. Investors questioned his approach.

The problem? Markets aren't purely logical. Emotions, politics, and randomness create noise that math alone can't predict. Simons first applied mathematical models assuming price movements followed predictable patterns. But reality didn’t cooperate. His strategies — statistical arbitrage, pattern recognition, and trend-following — were inspired by his background in geometry and cryptography, and needed fine-tuning.

How he bounced back: Chain-smoking his way through setbacks, he refined his approach, hired brilliant minds, and adjusted his models. He learned that short-term price movements had hidden patterns, but only if you looked deep enough.

The result? The Medallion Fund — one of the most successful hedge funds in history, delivering an extraordinary 66% annualized return with consistency.

Lesson? If something isn’t working, iterate — but don’t give up on a great idea too soon.

Simons passed away in May last year, leaving behind a legacy that transformed finance.

4️⃣ The $4,000 Mistake That Changed Everything

Before managing billions at Bridgewater, Ray Dalio was a young trader with absolute confidence in his analysis. That confidence nearly cost him everything.

In 1982, Dalio was convinced a major downturn was coming. The signals seemed clear — soaring debt, aggressive Fed policies, and the Latin American debt crisis. He publicly predicted an economic collapse and bet heavily.

The market proved him wrong. The economy rebounded. Markets surged, and Dalio’s positions blew up.

He almost lost everything. Worse, he had to lay off all his employees and borrow $4,000 from his dad just to stay afloat. Bridgewater, which he had started out of his apartment, was hanging by a thread.

How he bounced back: Humbled, Dalio realized he wasn’t as smart as he thought. He re-evaluated his approach, embracing radical transparency and independent thinking. Instead of trusting his own conviction, he started treating mistakes like puzzles, actively seeking dissenting opinions to challenge his views.

This became the foundation of Bridgewater’s now-famous ‘principles’ — a culture of brutal honesty, rigorous debate, and learning from failure.

That shift in mindset fueled Bridgewater’s rise into one of the world’s largest hedge funds.

Lesson? No matter how sure you are, the market doesn't care. Build systems to challenge your thinking before the market does it for you.

✒ Final Thoughts

What do all these legends have in common? They made risky bets that sometimes led to massive losses. But instead of letting failure define them, they turned it into fuel. Whether it was cutting losses (Ackman), managing liquidity (Griffin), refining a system (Simons), or rethinking principles (Dalio), each one found a way to turn setbacks into comebacks.

Markets are brutal, but the best investors don’t just survive — they adapt and evolve.

Until next time,
PE Bro

A Message from our Sponsor

Looking for unbiased, fact-based news? Join 1440 today.

Join over 4 million Americans who start their day with 1440 – your daily digest for unbiased, fact-centric news. From politics to sports, we cover it all by analyzing over 100 sources. Our concise, 5-minute read lands in your inbox each morning at no cost. Experience news without the noise; let 1440 help you make up your own mind. Sign up now and invite your friends and family to be part of the informed.

Subscribe to 1440 today.

Partnerships

Are you a Financial Services firm looking to connect with an engaged audience?

I am currently closing my Q2/Q3 sponsors. Please reach out if interested.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely my own and are provided for informational purposes only. This content is not intended to be financial advice. The examples and figures mentioned may vary and may not account for all possible scenarios or regional differences. Always seek the guidance of a qualified financial advisor or professional before making any investment decisions.